As science advances you will see that this will be the argument/policy that ultimately ends abortion.
A baby, fetus, node, whatever you want to call it, is alive after conception. All of science in every other field defines life and alive that way. Thus if it is alive, then what is it? Is it a plant, a dog, a an alien? No, it is a human, and can only grow to become a human, nothing else. Eventually as science and medicine can allow the human baby to survive earlier and earlier- probably up to the point of conception- then we will all agree that "life" begins at conception. However until then, congress could define life. So how does that solve the abortion debate?
First, right now of course the legal debate is mostly about whether a mother has a fundamental right to choose to kill the thing growing inside her. That is what Roe vs Wade was about and then PP v. Casey said that based on the allocation of burden on the mother, at some point during the pregnancy (when there is no undue burden on the mother) abortion can be prohibited. Ok, for the sake of this argument, lets say that that always stays the same, Casey and Roe are never overturned. So we assume there is a fundamental right at stake for the mother.
Next, and this is the cornerstone, if we legislatively define life as beginning at conception, then the courts cannot change that. The courts can only interpret the law, they do not make changes to clear law. Thus if there is a life at stake, then the due process clause is implicated. Under the 5th amendment the federal government, nor the states (via incorporation) can deprive a person of life without due process of law. Of course the due process clause only applies to government action, however this would mean that before any government deprivation of the babies life it would be entitled to a due process hearng. Thus any legislation that approves of, funds or provides for abortions would equally have to provide such a pre-deprivation hearing. Furthermore, any laws that seek to protect that life would have the additional weight of protecting the same sort of fundamental right that abortionists seek to protect. This would effectivly rebalance the test used in Roe v. Wade.
For instance, in such a hearing, we would have two competing fundamental rights at stake, the mothers fundamental right to abortion, and the babies fundamental (5th amendment due process) right to life. The process, procedure and rules for that hearing would have to be provided for by law so the government would be hard pressed to pass the strict scrutiny test in providing abortions, yet they would pass the strict scrutiny test for prohibiting them.
How? Under substantive due process and Roe v. Wade jurisprudence, the deprivation of a fundamental right by legislation must pass the strict scrutiny test. This means in essence that the legislation must serve a compelling governmental interest, be narrowly tailored, and have no less burdensome alternatives available to serve that compelling interest. Well, protecting another fundamental right of another human being would be a compelling interest. Abortion rights activists could argue the same about the abortion right. However is the law narrowly tailored? Well if the law is designed to preserve the babies life (in the absence of the mothers life being at risk) - then the law could certainly be narrowly tailored. However is a law providing for the protection of the mothers right to make her "medical decision"? Well that's arguable but we'll say it parallels the reverse argument. And last, are there any less burdensome ways to prevent the mother from paying someone to kill the baby than forbidding it to happen? I don't know of any. However, there certainly less burdonsome ways to protect the mothers interest in her medical decision etc. than to kill the baby. So the last element would kill any legislation that allowed for or provided abortions.
So laws that prohibit abortion at all ages of the baby would be valid under the US Constitution And laws that allow or fund abortions would not be valid under the US Constitution. If and when we simply acknowledge and define life like science does in other fields.
Any comments? Any loopholes you see?
Showing posts with label abortion. Show all posts
Showing posts with label abortion. Show all posts
Friday, May 4, 2007
Tuesday, April 24, 2007
Where are you taking us today master?
Democrats, Democrats, Demoncrats.
Where are you taking us today. I read the following article this morning and said, hmm it's nice to hear someone in the public with a major microphone pointing out the obvious. I wondered to myself, why does it take the Vatican to bring these points into the air? Is our drive-by media just ignoring it? Or are they encouraging it? Probably. And our conservative media is either to scared to speak out, or has lost their guts. Here is the article I am talking about... It made me think about where the Democrats and their policies are taking us.
http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20070423/wl_nm/pope_gays_dc
Democrats have led the way to:
Abortion-
the killing of defenseless babies at a marketplace- aka "voluntary interruption of pregnancy" takes place at a "center for reproductive health". The terrorists in Iraq saw off the heads of innocent adult reporters captured, our doctors here do the same thing to babies that are captured on their way out of the womb (notice Republicans banned partial birth abortion, Democrats got all upset).
Poverty- (particularly for minorities)
we now trap people into welfare and poverty by teaching them generation after generation that the government will always be there for them, no matter how bad they screw up. Don't worry about responsibility or educating yourself... the Democrats will take other responsible peoples money and give it to you. (need examples? oh boy don't get me started here; see Democrats oppostion to privatizing social security and opposing welfare to work; and their support of unions, etc.) Affirmative action supporters (Democrats) claim it helps, but what it really says is "you aren't good enough to do it by yourself". Republicans say "yes you can do it, we believe in you".
Homosexuality-
what was once nearly universally known as improper sexual behavior is now everywhere! TV, our public education system, sex-ed classes.
Genocide-
At one time it was wrong to kill people. Now you just have to say it is mercy. And thanks to the Democrats in Oregon we even have a pretty name for it "Death with Dignity". Remember how the proponents argued that the number of Euthanizations would not rise in Oregon, well it has increased every year that it has been allowed. I think it's strange how Democrats seem to care about the genocide in Darfur, but would be ok with allowing genocide and civil war in Iraq.
WE HAVE IT ALL IN OREGON- That's right you can get it all right here! And what's more, we have the state subsidize most of it. Including:
Drunkenness-
The state government owns all the liquor stores, that's right, the person you think owns it, actually has a lease. The state is selling the boose to you and me ;-).
Gambling-
A long time ago, Oregon said "we don't want gambling that is a vice, and we should prohibit it completely". Now the state sponsors it because it is a huge source of tax revenue, but can private individuals benefit from it? Nope, only the government can profit from such a profitable business in Oregon. But don't the Democrats care about the poor? Apparently not, they don't want people to be able to make any money, and they want people to gamble and loose what they have. (ALL studies show that the poor gamble -particularly on lotteries- at a much higher rate than the wealthy the Volberg study suggests that 5% of Oregon's population has some degree of gambling problem; that the poor spend about 14% more of their income on gambling than higher income groups; and that poor have a 6% more likelihood of being a problem gambler). Governor Kulongoski stated in 1996 when he headed a gambling study group that we needed to halt the expansion of gambling until we got the results of this study. Apparently those results on the poor didn't affect Ted, because gambling in Oregon, both lottery and casino is moving full speed ahead. Maybe the tribal funds that went to his campaign fund had something to do with that. Maybe if us private citizens and businessmen gave him that much money we could run casinos too. (wait no, I forgot Democrats don't actually care about free enterprise, they like government enterprise).
Democrats seem to want us: (if they don't abort us) poor, drunken, and under their control. Shoot that sounds like a good election strategy to me too! No wonder the Vatican is the only one talking about this, they don't get elected.
Where are you taking us today. I read the following article this morning and said, hmm it's nice to hear someone in the public with a major microphone pointing out the obvious. I wondered to myself, why does it take the Vatican to bring these points into the air? Is our drive-by media just ignoring it? Or are they encouraging it? Probably. And our conservative media is either to scared to speak out, or has lost their guts. Here is the article I am talking about... It made me think about where the Democrats and their policies are taking us.
http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20070423/wl_nm/pope_gays_dc
Democrats have led the way to:
Abortion-
the killing of defenseless babies at a marketplace- aka "voluntary interruption of pregnancy" takes place at a "center for reproductive health". The terrorists in Iraq saw off the heads of innocent adult reporters captured, our doctors here do the same thing to babies that are captured on their way out of the womb (notice Republicans banned partial birth abortion, Democrats got all upset).
Poverty- (particularly for minorities)
we now trap people into welfare and poverty by teaching them generation after generation that the government will always be there for them, no matter how bad they screw up. Don't worry about responsibility or educating yourself... the Democrats will take other responsible peoples money and give it to you. (need examples? oh boy don't get me started here; see Democrats oppostion to privatizing social security and opposing welfare to work; and their support of unions, etc.) Affirmative action supporters (Democrats) claim it helps, but what it really says is "you aren't good enough to do it by yourself". Republicans say "yes you can do it, we believe in you".
Homosexuality-
what was once nearly universally known as improper sexual behavior is now everywhere! TV, our public education system, sex-ed classes.
Genocide-
At one time it was wrong to kill people. Now you just have to say it is mercy. And thanks to the Democrats in Oregon we even have a pretty name for it "Death with Dignity". Remember how the proponents argued that the number of Euthanizations would not rise in Oregon, well it has increased every year that it has been allowed. I think it's strange how Democrats seem to care about the genocide in Darfur, but would be ok with allowing genocide and civil war in Iraq.
WE HAVE IT ALL IN OREGON- That's right you can get it all right here! And what's more, we have the state subsidize most of it. Including:
Drunkenness-
The state government owns all the liquor stores, that's right, the person you think owns it, actually has a lease. The state is selling the boose to you and me ;-).
Gambling-
A long time ago, Oregon said "we don't want gambling that is a vice, and we should prohibit it completely". Now the state sponsors it because it is a huge source of tax revenue, but can private individuals benefit from it? Nope, only the government can profit from such a profitable business in Oregon. But don't the Democrats care about the poor? Apparently not, they don't want people to be able to make any money, and they want people to gamble and loose what they have. (ALL studies show that the poor gamble -particularly on lotteries- at a much higher rate than the wealthy the Volberg study suggests that 5% of Oregon's population has some degree of gambling problem; that the poor spend about 14% more of their income on gambling than higher income groups; and that poor have a 6% more likelihood of being a problem gambler). Governor Kulongoski stated in 1996 when he headed a gambling study group that we needed to halt the expansion of gambling until we got the results of this study. Apparently those results on the poor didn't affect Ted, because gambling in Oregon, both lottery and casino is moving full speed ahead. Maybe the tribal funds that went to his campaign fund had something to do with that. Maybe if us private citizens and businessmen gave him that much money we could run casinos too. (wait no, I forgot Democrats don't actually care about free enterprise, they like government enterprise).
Democrats seem to want us: (if they don't abort us) poor, drunken, and under their control. Shoot that sounds like a good election strategy to me too! No wonder the Vatican is the only one talking about this, they don't get elected.
Labels:
abortion,
assisted suicide,
gambling,
genocide
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)